Vintage Perfume Review: Rochas Femme (Edmond Roudnitska) 1944 ~ Foreword by Michel Roudnitska + The True Story Draw

Michel with his father Edmond Roudnistka (photo property of Michel and shared with Michelyn in 2010)

There is no doubt in my mind that Rochas Femme,  composed in 1944, is a stunning, classic beauty and that the creator, Edmond Roudnitska, was one of the most talented perfumers of the 20th century.  Before I begin my review of this masterpiece, the remarkable perfumer, shaman and activist  Michel Roudnistska, Edmond' Roudnitska's son, has been kind enough to share with  our readers the true story of the creation of Femme.

Marcel Rochas and Mae West 1934

Edmond Roudnitska met Marcel Rochas in 1943 during World War II. This “couturier” was at the top of the French Haute Couture and was looking for a very feminine fragrance. Edmond was at that time rather experienced in creating “bases” for De Laire Company in Paris, but still a beginner in fine fragrance composition. With a very limited choice of raw materials (due to the German occupation) he had just freely composed one fragrance with a new fruity (peach/plum) “accord” based on Prunol and “Fut 5”. In November 1943 he presented this unique sample to Marcel Rochas who accepted it immediately, without any discussion, without any modification. This perfume has been launched by IPO (subscription) under the name of “Femme” after the liberation of Paris, during a collection at the end of 1944. The bottle of white and pink crystal, inspired by Mae West and designed by Lalique, was magnificent. This fragrance was immediately a success as it was the first fine fragrance launched after the war.

In 1989 Olivier Cresp was asked to retool this perfume, making Edmond Roudnitska sadly say: “They stole my “Femme”. Michel Roudnitska for ÇaFleureBon, 2017

Vintage Ad Rochas Femme  1961

Rochas Femme has been part of my life for as long as I can remember.  When I was a little girl a tiny bottle of Femme perfume was one of the many fragrances displayed on my mother's dressing table. I loved the black lace patterned box but dared not open it. As a young teenager I would sneak a dab of Femme on occasion and to this day remember the succulent peaches and ripe plums replete with an odd dustiness and a sharp edge that I didn't quite understand.  Femme was mysterious and carnal but did nothing to satisfy my naïve, young nose.  I was drawn to more overt and accessible beauties; to my mother's big perfume powerhouses like Sirocco and Jungle Gardenia and to the bright and bracing complexity of Lanvin's now long discontinued Spanish Geranium.  Over the years I have maintained an ambivalent relationship with Femme Rochas, loving or loathing her, but always returning to her warm, voluptuous femininity.

Rita Hayworth as Gilda the ultimate femme fatale 1946

The name itself  – "Femme" – is open to several interpretations.  The word suggests a number of images, the first of which is the sweet, pretty, compliant young woman, the type that was sanctioned by the traditional dominant male culture of the early 20th century.  Another  "femme" is the gender/role designation that began to be used in the1950s/60s referring to "submissive" women in same sex relationships. And then, of course, there is the notorious "femme fatale" who wields both intellectual and sexual power. Charismatic and shrewd, she uses her intense, manipulative sexuality to get exactly what she wants from men and from life. This "femme" exudes self-confidence, control and at the same time an inexplicable vulnerability that can be every man's sexual fantasy – or darkest nightmare.   While the perfume Femme suggests (to me) all of these feminine modalities it is not confined to any of one them.

Mae West inspired Femme

In 1943/44 Edmond Roudnitska created Femme at the request of Marcel Rochas for Rochas third wife Hélène.  Roudnitska was inspired by one of the most notorious and powerful femme fatales of the silver screen – Mae West.  The perfumer used Prunol for the peachy sugarplum and laced this semi-gourmand with lemon and aldehyldes, fortified with dusty immortelle. At the heart ylang, jasmine, rose, spices and orris rested on a disturbing base of civet, musk, amber and benzoin.  The bottle suggested the figure of Mae West and the black lace patterns on the box referenced the lacey wasp waist corsets designed by Marcel Rochas.

 

Now what, if anything, does Femme the perfume have to do with feminism? From my aging perspective, mid 20th century feminism – AKA Women's Liberation – was at odds with the femme fatale as well as with many  other traditionally feminine roles.  In the 70s certain feminists went so far as to consider the promotion and use of perfumes like Femme to be politically incorrect, regressive and predatory.  In those days I was a young married mom and housewife, migrating and nesting with my young family in various locations around the world. Instead of being liberated by early feminism I felt pigeon holed, demeaned and patronized simply because I did not work outside of the home.  I was happy to be a homemaker and felt totally fulfilled in my role as mother and wife, but the notion that I should be "liberated" cast a shadow on my contentment. That being said, my bottle of Femme perfume was rarely used, as it was often too provocative, rich and ripe for my practical homemaker's taste.  Make no mistake, though, I was a party girl as well as a mom. But in those days it was green, resinous galbanum, rather than ripe plums that made me feel sexy and powerful and my favorite fragrance was Guy Laroche Fidji.

Monica Belluci is 52 photo by Sandrine Dulermo and Michael Labica for Citizen K International, Spring 2016

Over the years, as life and circumstances have changed, I began to appreciate and resonate with the ideals and goals of a new feminism.  As the movement evolved it no longer seemed to be at odds with the role of housewife and mother or the motives and manipulative power of the femme fatale.  Now, in my mid 60s, I have learned that the most radical and "feminist" thing any woman can do is simply be the person she really is and say what she really means, whether that be about politics, perfume or anything else!  I have also come to a genuine appreciation and love for the unabashed and honest sexuality of the original Femme. At long last, I believe I have developed a better understanding of my 1950s vintage Rochas Femme, the same scent (albeit it aged), in the same lace patterned box that graced my mother's dressing table so many years ago.

Gail Gross – Sr. Contributor

Early1980s bottle collage Dawn Spencer Hurwitz

Art Direction: Michelyn whose first grown-up perfume was Rochas Femme gifted to me  by a  French gentleman while I lived in Paris (which may explain my penchant for peach and plum notes as well as prunol in my personal fragrances). Dawn Spencer Hurwitz created Reveries de Paris for me, which took seven years, based on my experiences as a young woman and my love of Rochas Femme.

We are offering  a 10 ml decant of the original vintage formula Rochas Femme EDP  from a bottle Michel gifted Michelyn (marked 1959)  when they met in NYC in 2008 to one registered reader in the EU, USA or Canada. (Be sure to register or your comment will not count.) To be eligible for the draw please let us know  whay you thought of Gail’s review (if you agree with her that being a feminist doesn’t preclude you from being a femme fatale), Michel Roudnitksa’s  true story, and where you live or comment on feminism and honest sexuality. Draw closes 1/8/2016

We announce the winners only on site and on our Facebook page, so Like Cafleurebon and use our RSS feed…or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

83 − 80 =

18 comments

  • Thank you for the wonderful drawing! Great article. In my opinion being a feminist simply means being able to be any type of person you want to be, without having to confirm to outside definitions.

  • Very interesting article! That the sample Edmond Roudnitska gave Marcel Rochas was made with limited ingredients and experience, yet was immediately accepted, shows his ability as a perfumer. I know a few young women who are unabashably femme fatales. I have often felt that the Women’s Liberation movement went the wrong way when it wanted to deny everything traditionally feminine. That you for this draw. I live in the US.

  • DNEM, absolutely wnderful article, Gail!! And honoring Mae West one of the original 20th Century feminists was a stroke of genius!

  • I think that a part of our nature is that of the femme fatale. To deny it is to deny that part of ourselves. Being oneself can be the most seductive. I so appreciated learning the history of this fragrance. Thank you for the draw. iI live in the USA.

  • What a delightful surprise that Michel Roudnitska told the real story behind Rochas Femme no modification and sadly they reformulate dos Edmond Roudnitska said they stole his femme
    The way Gail talked about Femme as part of her life even when she thought it was out of style but realized that being a feminist means being yourself sexy and a femme fatale.
    How lucky Michelyn to have met Michel and that he gave her a bottle of the original
    I loved the review and special story
    Thank you cafleurebon
    USA

  • I love the true story of Rochas Femme. It adds a special something to the perfume as does knowing about the bottle. I am a great fan of Mae West. She was one of a kind! Gail’s description of what being a feminist is is *right-on*. 😉 “I have learned that the most radical and “feminist” thing any woman can do is simply be the person she really is and say what she really means”. USA.

  • It’s such a revelation to read about the beauty of vintage masterpieces in their original form… I’ve only tried Femme in semi vintage but honestly it feels melancholic and femme fatale at the same time. Loved the review, and would love to be able to try the version Edmond envisioned for 1940’s black and white era!
    I live in Spain should I win!!!
    Happy new year!

  • fazalcheema says:

    I don’t think being a feminist and femme fatale is mutually exclusive though I do have an issue with women who simply behind the feminist label to promote their personal brands and could not care less about the overall state of women right (for e.g. kardashians and their posse). I felt sat at the fact that Edmund had to see reformulation of his beloved fragrance. I do have a vintage femme but it is most probably from 70s-80s and not the original from 40s or 50s so I don’t know how much it may be different from original femme. thanks for the draw. I am in US.

  • Absolutely! The feminist movement is about liberation, making us all free to express ourselves woithout constraining gender stereotypes. So to me that means a freedom to among other things express sexuality/sensuality/gender however we wish. Now, I’m completely asexual and aromantic to boot, but even so I don’t mind the overt sensuality of a femme fatale fume, I even love these sorts of fragrances and would be thrilled to try some vintage Femme!

    I’m in Finland (EU). Thank you for the draw!

  • doveskylark says:

    I believe that a woman should be allowed to be as sexual as she wants to be. But remember, it’s a very powerful thing, expressing sexuality in a visual way. I remember studying abroad in Italy in the early 90s. Many of the women on the program loved the attention they received from Italian men. But I remember one classmate came home crying after a dinner date with an Italian man. “He only asked me out to have sex with me,” she said between sobs. We comforted her, but we were also like, “What the hell did you expect?”
    I have the same book, “The Paris I Love.”
    I wear Femme just because it smells nice.
    I live in the USA.

  • I dislike the idea that feminism is about self expression because that’s simply called having a personality. The suffix -ist means taking action, like an activist, not just living however you personally desire and declaring it a revolution by fiat.

    Like the author, I also have a bottle of Femme that I rarely touch.

  • I loved this article! Although I consider myself to be a very liberated woman, I have never called myself a feminist. I adore the ultra feminine attributes of perfume and I thank you for this incredible draw! I have always been a fan of Dawn Hurvitz and Michel Roudnitksa. A beautiful perfume.

  • Hikmat Sher Afridi says:

    Thanks for the article & review! Think about the time of this historic fragrance of 1940’s & 1980’s and the answer was a beautiful chypre and a masterpiece ROCHAS FEMME, the fragrance for the hard working, strong & bold women. FEMME is the translation of a woman IMO.
    Michelyn & Gail Gross you both and few subscribers are lucky enough being owner of the vintage ROCHAS FEMME.
    Thanks for the generosity for 10ml vintage version of ROCHAS FEMME and Cafleurebon for the opportunity to participate in the draw by letting me my relative address in US.

  • What a wonderful article! I am a fan of Mae West and Femme is surely one of the scents she would choose for herself: a full, brave femininity in the bottle. It would be great to win this vintage treasure.

    (EU)

  • Origin stories are fascinating, especially for perfume, as it is rare to be gifted with the details of motivation and history which result in something so beautiful. It is wonderful that the story of Femme has not been lost in time. Thank you to Gail for sharing her thoughts and some of her life story. I also remember smelling Femme when I was a child. I did not understand it, but I knew it was powerful. And thank you to Michelyn for the marvelous and evocative pictures of feminine power. I think feminism and femme-ism can co-exist. Both are attributes that describe a clarity of purpose which is very much like a well-made fragrance, where one is exactly what one purports to be, nothing more and nothing less. DNEM as I have two vials of Femme, one old and one more recent, that were sent to me by a wonderful perfumista not too long ago.

  • I couldn’t agree more with Gail’s thoughts on feminism’s:
    the most radical and “feminist” thing any woman can do is simply be the person she really is and say what she really means, whether that be about politics, perfume or anything else!”
    Rochas Femme perfume accepts a woman’s nature the way she chooses to be! Femme fatale doesn’t exclude being a feminist instead is part of a woman’s sexuality, being expressed the way one chooses to do when she feels like it!
    I loved Femme Rochas Michel Roudnitksa’s true story, it’s always nice to know the story behind a mythical perfume.
    Thank you dear Michelyn and Gail for the opportunity to win such a mythical scent and for the generous 10ml sample! Thank you also for the lovely review!
    I am a registered reader living in EU, Greece.

  • My mother kept a tiny bottle of Femme in her dressing table, and only brought it out for dates. I loved to steal a sniff or two of it. In the 1970s I bought a bottle of the Femme eau d’toilette and powder. I lost both in a move, and when I got around to buying it again, discovered it had been horribly changed. So sad. Gome was the sensuality.

    I would love to find a custom perfume mixer who could recreate it for me.