Niche Fragrance Review: For Strange Women – Naturally Capturing the Scents of Memories + A Memorable Prize Draw

For Strange Women Header

For Strange Women

A couple of years ago a group of perfumistas were discussing how much we loved the smell of our cats’ fur and wishing there was a perfume that could emulate it. One person found a link for a perfume called Winter Kitty, and, being the impulsive person I am, I ordered some. The company was called For Strange Women, which I thought was a great name. I followed them on Facebook and had them in the back of my mind until I saw a post asking if there were bloggers out there who wanted to review the perfumes. Curious about the other scents in the line, I asked perfumer Jill McKeever to send me some samples. I received three from the Black Forest Solids line, consisting of Fireside Story, Nightshade Garden, and Black Forest Cake. The samples are bits of perfumed wax between folded ribbon, that you heat in your hands before applying. The benefit to this is that you get a sense of the perfume as it wafts from the ribbon without having to sniff at the stick in a tiny vial or spray a piece of paper. Each is packaged in a little wax paper envelope.

The perfumes are all-natural, and crafted from carefully sourced materials from scratch in Ms. McKeever’s Kansas City studio. She specializes in scents that evoke memories and sensations. She offers her solids in beautiful amulets, and the oils come in classic brown apothecary bottles. The aesthetic is pleasing: modern, but with a sense of feminine Gothic and Victorian sensibility. She also makes lip balms and other products that are equally appealing. The packaging is earth-friendly.

For Strange Women 1 Winter Kitty CaFleureBon

Searching for Aslan by Zenera

First off, let me say that I love Winter Kitty. It is meant to evoke the scent of a cat’s fur when it has come in from being outside romping in the pines and snow. The perfume captures that smell admirably, although my own cat is more likely to smell like skunk and vacant lot. What the perfume is successful at achieving is the warm, slightly animal smell of that furry belly that so many of us like to stick our faces in when our cats are warm and happy. The crisp, minty fir top, smelling like the great outdoors, is a nice counterpoint. It really does smell like a winter kitty.

Notes: Douglas fir, mint, Moroccan rose, vanilla bourbon, vetiver, and wood

For Strange Women 2 Nightshade CaFleureBon

Grandfather's Garden by George Henry

The first ribbon I heated up was Nightshade Garden, which was inspired by the scent of tomato vines. A crisp, sweet citrus opening is mellowed by leafy greens. I put it on my décolleté and wrists, and when I huffed down my shirt, where the scent had been warmed, I got a whiff of my grandpa’s tomato garden in the summer, just enough to create the memory, but not so much that I smelled like a tomato. Because it was cool outside, the scent on my wrists was more herbal. I enjoyed wearing this scent, but would like to try it again on a warmer day so it blooms.

Notes: Citrus, fruit tree leaves, bay, and olive leaf (extrapolated from descriptions on the website)

For Strange women 3 Black Forest CaFleureBon

For Strange Women

I am not allowed to eat Black Forest cake, since it is full of cherries that have been soaked in Kirschwasser, and I don’t consume alcohol. I can get my fix with Black Forest Cake perfume. Chocolate in perfume is something I wasn’t sure about until I started smelling fragrances made with natural cacao. There is a dense, almost bitter, earthy quality that makes it imminently wearable. This scent has been blended with just a touch of floral notes, and possibly some vanilla, to sweeten it just enough but not turn it into candy. It’s very pretty and I like it, but the name of it made me think there might be a bit of black cherry in it, which would be kind of fun. Although the chocolate is dominant, there are underlying aromas that add complexity and an almost smoky quality. I am especially taken with a woody note that is soft and creamy, with a fresh sawdust vibe. If you are intimidated by chocolate in perfume, you might like this despite yourself.

Notes: Cacao, woods, florals, and spices

For Strange Women 4 Fireside CaFleureBon

Glandon Family, US National Archives

I tend to not have fireplaces in my own homes, so have to enjoy their hypnotic flames and warmth when I am elsewhere. Applying Fireside Story immediately brought to mind a mountain home my family had at one point, where we used to spend our Christmases. The walls were wood paneled and the fireplace sported the obligatory deer head, named Charlie. We would gather in front of the fire and play Scrabble ™ or just chat and have snacks. We used to burn the occasional pine cone, and that aroma is present in this fragrance. Walking in the snow, we would be able to smell the home fire in the crisp air. This perfume is that waft of welcoming smoke, along with woody resins and a touch of sweetness. Fireside Story is one of the prettiest perfumes I have smelled in the genre of “things that are burning”.

Notes: Woods, leaves, pine cones, dried resins, three kinds of vanilla

After testing these three scents that are new to me, and wearing Winter Kitty again, I think that this is a line that bears heavy exploration. Ms. McKeever has a knack for recreating scent memory using natural ingredients, but the perfumes are also easy to wear, which some sense-memory evoking perfumes miss. They don’t hit you over the head, merely softly evoke, which is lovely. I am anxious now to try the rest of the line. As with most natural perfumes, you do need to re-apply after a while, and the sillage is fairly close. With perfumes like this, that feel so personal, having them just create a wispy veil is preferable to leaving a huge scent trail, for me, anyway.

For Strange Women Draw Prizes

For Strange Women products are available on their website, and there is a good sample program. Ms. McKeever has kindly offered a choice of either a Deluxe Sampler of 14 solid scents, or a 7.3 ml bottle of Winter Kitty perfume oil. Please leave a comment letting us know which you would prefer. Draw ends February 8, 2013.

We announce the winners only on site and on our Facebook page, so Like Cafleurebon and use our RSS option…or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume.

Tama Blough, Senior Editor

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

9 × = 45

81 comments

  • Ooh, this line sounds divine. I would love a bottle of Winter Kitty if I’m lucky enough to win the draw.

  • I love Winter Kitty! The 7.3 ml bottle is my choice!
    FSW is a great line, under the radar.
    Thank you for the draw.

  • I’d love the Deluxe Sampler (I want to try them all!! 🙂 ).

    I’ve followed this perfumer for a while now, but am yet to have the opportunity to sampler her scents (postage to Oz is a killer!). I just love the aesthetics of the FSW brand.

    Many thanks for a wonderful draw!

    Holly

  • I had to laugh at the brand name, sounds like something I could love.
    I would love a chance to win the deluxe sampler.

    Thanks for the draw!

  • As good as Winter Kitty sounds, I absolutely have to try more from this line. They sound incredible and I love the aesthetic.

  • Oh, these all sound wonderful! I’m especially captivated by the description of Winter Kitty, and that would be my choice. Thank you for the draw, and for the pitch perfect artwork that accompanies this post.

  • francescabelanger says:

    I’d love to sniff the sample pack. I’d never heard of this line before and it sounds really interesting.

  • Oh, I LOVE the sound of these, and just followed them on FB, too! I would be so happy to win the Winter Kitty perfume oil. Thanks so much for the lovely reviews, and the opportunity to try this!

  • This sounds totally my speed, lol! I would love to try the deluxe sampler. Thanks for the intro to this line! 🙂

  • Oh, I loved this review, it made me laugh! The name alone, For ‘Strange Women’ is spot on and the idea of creating the scent of a favored feline is on my to do list as well.
    But your descriptions of the wax scents really piqued my curiosity so I’d love to try the sample set!
    Thank you

  • Great revie, for me it has to be the Black Forest Cake since I am allowed to eat Black Forest cake, and love that it is full of cherries that have been soaked in Kirschwasser, eventhough I do not often consume alcohol. Reminds me of home. Schwarzwalder Kirch Torte/Kuchen as we call it at home!!!!

  • As much as I’d love to try the 14 scents in the sampler, I think it would be much cooler to have a kitty scented perfume oil. Thank you for this draw.

  • I would love to try the Deluxe Sampler of 14 solid scents. Mainly because I would love to try them all. Only too bad that Winter Kitty isn’t one of the samples.

  • Does anyone else like the smell of cats’ feet after they have been all curled up asleep?!
    Winter Kitty please!

  • OMG! The description of Winter Kitty is just so witty! And the picture is to die for. AND the bottle is lovely! I love it! Winter Kitty please!

  • Oh, I love the smell of my cat’s fur — she’s an indoor kitty, but sometimes I think she smells a bit like popcorn. So Winter Kitty it is for me, too!

  • I just adopted a tortie kitty from the aniimal shelter…the lovely Miss Sasha…so my pick would be Winter Kitty!

  • If I win, I’d like the Winter Kitty but I think I’m going to visit their site to sample the others scents, I want to try the Fireside story.

  • I too am new to this line and I’d love to try Winter Kitty. I wonder what my dog will think?

  • I love cats. I’ve volunteered for many cat and animal rescue foundations in my community. Helping with shelters, adoptions, socializing, advertising, outreach, etc. I paint and draw cats, love to photograph cats. Yep, I love cats.

    So, it would def be Winter Kitty for me!!! Sounds wonderful!!

  • I would live to try the deluxe sampler. All of them sound interesting. I should try them all. Thank you!

  • This sounds like so much fun and I would love to try the sampler set. Thanks for drawing my attention to another line to explore.

  • I have 2 rescue kitties (my daughter wants to save all the animals), and a rescue dog. I would love to try the sampler or the Winter Kitty. Thanks.

  • I am so happy to have heard about this line of natural perfumes.
    They all sound so lovely. I’d love to try the sampler set if I should be the lucky one picked. thanks!

  • These fragrances sound luscious, especially the Black Forest Cake and Fireside Story. I would really like to try the sampler set. Thanks for the draw.

  • I am very curious to try these perfumes especially winter kitty! If I won I’d like the sample set. Thank you!!

  • All this fragances sounds nice, and as I have a cat who never goes out , I would like to try the winter kitty!

  • Winter Kitty, cause my favorite thing is cuddling my cat when I feel stressed or down, if I have this oil it will remind me of kitty cuddles anytime

  • These all sound great! If I win, I’d like the sampler set. (I’m thinking winter kitty, which sounds so nice, will be one of the samples in the set!) Thank you for the drawing.

  • Great review!I’ve never heard about this brand before and I’ve never tried solid perfumes, so I’d like to choose the sampler set.Thanks for the the draw !

  • Samantha S. says:

    For Strange Women is such a beautiful store. Out of the ones you reviewed, I’ve only tried Fireside Story, which has become my favorite FSW perfume. It’s magical!
    I’m so interested in the Deluxe Sampler! What a lovely giveaway.

  • What an wonderful line of scents! Thank you for the review. In honor of my cats, I would like Winter Kitty 🙂

  • amberosmanthus says:

    Oh how I love Winter Kitty! I have a small sample and have been hoarding it forever, always meaning to buy a bottle. Please add me to the draw for Winter Kitty! This is one of my all time favorites.

  • Being a huge animal lover, loving the way my kitty’s fur smells, and reading the description and reviews on her web site, I would definitely love to try Winter Kitty. Thanks for the draw!

  • Oh wow, Winter Kitty–I love the cat on the website, and real cats, and would love to smell that scent! But I also love samples, and the sample set doesn’t include Winter Kitty….this is hard.

    I think I’d choose the sample set. But putting Winter Kitty on my must-sniff list! Thanks for the draw and reviews, I love learning about new lines!

  • I like idea of the solid perfume. Its application requires a small but nice ritual. I’d like to win Deluxe Sampler. Thanks.