New Niche Fragrance Review: Phoenicia Perfumes Gone But Not + Chemistry Done Right Draw

Phoenicia Gone but Not Header

David Falsberg

Perfumer David Falsberg of Phoenicia Perfumes has been on my radar for some time, but only now have I managed to snag samples of his perfumes. CaFleureBon profiled Mr. Falsberg earlier this year, and his story of becoming drawn to olfactory pursuits while temporarily blinded by an illness is compelling, to say the least. When I received a little box of samples from the FRAGments show in Los Angeles last month, I couldn’t wait to smell them.

Phoenicia Gone but Not #1 CaFleureBon

In The Laboratory by Jennifer Comstock

Rather than try to review the line, which is small but mighty, I decided to review the scent that really spoke to me, and is actually Mr. Falsberg’s favorite so far. Having worked predominantly with natural fragrance compounds, he wanted to expand his palette with high-quality synthetic aromachemicals.  Gone But Not is the first product of that exploration, and it is a beautiful, intriguing perfume.

Phoenicia Gone But Not #2 CaFleureBon

Flower Girl by Jasmine Ronel

Gone But Not opens with an intensely floral, boozy bouquet that almost makes me dizzy. One of the head notes is elemi, which I have smelled on its own, and is an odd, earthy, herbal aroma. It is quite evident in the opening of this perfume, and creates a unique atmosphere of antiquity that somehow shies away from being musty or outdated. It also adds a grounded natural feel that juxtaposes with the lift of the synthetics. As the scent progresses, the rose and jasmine notes start to shine. If ever a perfume had a shimmer, this is one; it is heady and bold. The musk in the base gives the perfume stockinged legs to stand on; just enough sex to keep things interesting.

Phoenicia Gone But Not #3 CaFleureBon

Public Art Piece by Nicole Dextras

Gone But Not is aptly named, because just as you think it has disappeared, you catch a little whiff of something lovely. I am sad that my sample was rather small, as I would have liked to give myself a good drenching. Mr. Falsberg describes this as “grandma’s Joy meets Grandpa’s Jovan Musk with an industrial hint of hair spray.”  I think it is more elegant than that description might lead you to believe, but it is a bit of a throwback to times when perfume was unabashedly and fearlessly worn to make a statement. I will definitely get my hands on more of this one.

Notes: fruit, elemi, cognac, white rose, jasmine, musk

Phoenicia Gone But Not Closer CaFleureBon

The Phoenicia Perfumes line has Skin Graft, which Mark Behnke has reviewed; a scent called Far NWest, redolent with evergreen; and a very true oud called Realoud (with a variation called Realoud Feral). He is launching a new honeyed floral, Rucher Fleuri, that I am anxious to smell.  Mr Falsberg is one to watch, and I will be watching closely.

I received my samples from Phoenicia Perfumes, and we have a 15 ml bottle of Gone But Not to give away to one lucky reader anywhere in the world. Leave a comment to enter, and remember that our sponsor cannot be liable or responsible for any packages detained or seized by customs. Draw ends August 2, 2013.

We announce the winners only on site and on our Facebook page, so like Cafleurebon and use our RSS option…or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume

Tama Blough, Senior Editor

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

4 × = 20

54 comments

  • Nice review! I have not yet had the pleasure to try any of the fragrances from this line, but would love to try them. Gone But Not sounds yummy! Thanks!

  • Well, I’m much more intrigued by Tama’s description of the perfume than by Mr. Falsberg’s. Joy meets Jovan Musk and industrial hairspray? No, thanks. But reading the review by Ms. Blough and the list of notes have renewed by interest. I’d like to try a sample. Thank you. (I know it’s a worldwide draw, but I’m in the US).

  • I have never smelled elemi before, and I am excited to have a new perfume line to explore. Thanks for the draw!

  • I love the strong note of elemi in Maison Francs Kurkdijan Oud so I would love try this one.
    Thanks
    USA

  • Awesome giveaway! I am lucky to have briefly smelled this as a work in progress and am very curious to try the finished product. I have no doubt, I will have the full Phoenicia line once finances are better. They’re all very evocative.

  • ElizabethN says:

    I had the pleasure of sniffing Skin Graft recently, and I would love to smell Gone but Not. Sounds wonderful!

  • This just reminds me that Skin Graft is on my to-try list. Would like the opportunity to try Gone But Not.

  • I was lucky enough to smell the Phoenicia line at Blackbird in Seattle, but haven’t tried them on my skin yet…something I very much look forward to. And I love the name Gone But Not! I live in the U.S.

  • The description of ‘Grandma’s Joy meeting Grandpa’s Jovan Musk’ got my attention and the added hint of industrial hairspray bit was just what makes this singular perfume on my must try list!
    Thank you for this draw.

  • Chapeau Clack says:

    Love the quirky name, and the notes sound interesting. Count me in please 🙂

  • I had the luck of getting REALOUD, which is a lovely mukhalat that I’m enjoying having, so I’d of course be interested in trying David’s new creation.

  • Never had the opportunity to try anything of Phoenicia Perfumes. Really interested though. Gone But Not sounds nice.

    Thanks for this lovely worldwide draw!

  • I love the name and the label, its elevation its mystery and it past present and future all in one- I bet this is really interesting and fingers crossed I’m hoping I’m a winner. David looks like fun too! 🙂

  • Fazal Cheema says:

    is this hairspray note in vintage fragrances for real..i have smelled so many vintage fragrances and still have not understood what a hairspray note is supposed to smell like…the only hairspray i used during high school was L’Oreal and it had kinda pleasant smell

  • Laurentiu says:

    I like the name: Gone but Not. Very curious about the smell. Thanks for the draw!

  • PatriciaC says:

    Very interesting review and kind of funny too, with the hairspray and boozie scent. Sounds cute and quirky-please enter me in the drawing, thank you.

  • Cognac note!? wow.

    White rose + jasmine combo just win me.

    Thank you for the draw =)

  • FearsMice says:

    I love it when a perfume takes me back to when it “was unabashedly and fearlessly worn”! Sounds intriguing; thanks for the draw!

  • The Elemi oil with its citrus/dill pickle note would make this quite interesting with a nice blending of new and old – natural and synthetic.

  • Fazal, when people refer to hairspray it is generally referring to a drugstore brand like Aqua Net. I don’t even know if you can still get that stuff!

  • Marion Low says:

    Rose, jasmine, a bit herbal, a touch of hairspray, retro 60’s? Count me in please. Love the company name, Phoenician. Thank you for the draw.

  • This sounds lovely. On a morbid note, this spoke to me – the name of the fragrance. Even if I don’t win, I’ll be searching this out to wear in remembrance of my baby who passed in May. He is gone, but not. I think of him daily but having a scent tied to thoughts of him would be special.

  • I love the idea of a fragrance shimmering. Sounds very interesting and I hope to have the opportunity to try it. Thanks for the draw and for bringing such interesting perfumers to our attention. I am in the U.S.

  • soupersusan says:

    Ooh, I’m very interested in a new, shimmery take on flowers. Please add me to the drawing. Many thanks!

  • Janet in California says:

    The name is wonderful! I have never tried anything by this house.

    Thanks!

  • Phoenicia Perfumes says:

    Devon H, please contact me through Phoenicia’s website if you do not win this draw. I want you to experience the fragrance, I have lost both my parents and even almost my own life in recent years and perfume just gets us through tough times. The name Gone But Not refers to a rock star I was watching on YouTube who is gone but lives on in his videos.

  • Thanks for the terrific give-away! Would love to try any of the fragrances by Phoenicia Perfumes 🙂

  • Elemi coupled with booze…sign me up. It sounds like something I would enjoy very much. Thanks for the great review and the draw.

  • Phoenica Perfumes, I was moved by what you wrote above. Yes, scent does help with hard times. There’s a type of therapy called “DBT” and one of the mnemonics is “self soothe with scent.” Scent/perfume is not just the luxury frivolity that most people think it is. I hope Devon wins!

  • Tama, thanks for writing about David’s creations! He is one of the most original and honest perfumers I know. No need to enter me in the draw.

  • The notes is this one sound amazing! I love love a chance to try this.

    Thanks for the draw!

  • Combination of cognac and white flowers sounds interesting. Would be great to win it, thanks

  • This looks to be a great fragrance. The notes sound interesting. Would be really nice to try.

    Thanks for the draw!

  • This sounds like a great fragrance. I’d love to win it. Might end up buying it. Thanks!

  • Gone but Not is also my favorite of David’s perfumes, it blew me away the first time I smelled it, and I return to it every couple of days to experience the magic. (it reminds me of my great grandmother, something violet dances above the soft muskiness …. David’s unique approach produces incredible fragrances, and they just keep on coming. He is a prolific creator offering pure genius in liquid form!