January 24, 2013
CaFleureBon Editors’ Best Cold Weather Scents + Outside In “A Winter’s Tale”- Five Bottle Fragrance Draw
Does a perfumista really need an excuse to try a new fragrance? A change in season is a good time to switch things up. T.S. Eliot said "April is the cruelest month"; we think it has been this January– brutally cold, an early flu season and heavy snow storms. The best winter scents are the ones we wear to warm up when the weather makes us shiver.
-Michelyn Camen, Editor-in Chief
I am not a snow bunny; I'd rather be indoors wafting my favorite winter perfumes that wrap me in their scented cocoon.
Gaiac by Parfums M.Micallef has been one of my favorite winter scents these past few days and every winter since I bought my first bottle five years ago. When it was first launched, I read somewhere it was a "men's" fragrance which was baffling because on me this is the perfume equivalent of a close fitting gown stitched in liquid gold. Rich, opulent with a heart of jasmine, Gaiac is a beautifully balanced blend of sweet resins, dry woods and sensuous spice. The clove and vanilla combo is unlike any I have ever smelled. Gaiac turns up the thermostat in just one spritz.
I understand why Mark made such a fuss about Rima XI by Carner Barcelona ; I fell in love and I fell hard. This fragrance is pure poetry (its based on the haunting verses of the same name by 19th century poet Gustavo Adolfo Becquer) and is best worn on a cold winter's eve when you lie wide awake and the room is so still you hear the sound of your own breathing. When I wear Rima XI, I dream of walking through a moonlit Andalusian garden redolent of night blooming jasmine and in the woody shadows he awaits me. A gentle lover, Rima XI beckons with its soft spicy breath of cardamom and nutmeg, as it binds you in "braids of gold" saffron. The slightly sweet amber and madagascar vanilla lulls you to sleep. Tender is the night.
-Mark Behnke, Managing Editor
There have been a few new additions to my winter rotation but there are two forever staples for me.
Guerlain Bois D’Armenie was, until recently, the only Guerlain incense fragrance. It is based on the burning incense papers called Papier D’Aremnie. This is an incense as only Guerlain could produce decadent and sweet with no sharp edges. It is just what I need as the temperature nose dives.
The other classic is Chanel Egoiste as it also just feels like the equivalent of an Irish Cable Knit sweater thick and warm and luxurious. Egoiste is what I pull on when I just want to stare into the fire.
Edouard Manet
-Tama Blough, Senior Editor
I have had the flu for about a month, so my most frequently worn scent has actually been Vick’s Vapo Rub ™, the scent of which I actually adore. In that vein, I have also been wearing Serge Luten’s mentholated beauty, Tubereuse Criminelle. The medicinal opening is actually my favorite part of the perfume, and when I am feeling congested and miserable it perks me up. The beauty of the tuberose heart makes me feel pretty and glamorous even if I’m spending the day in my pajamas, lounging with my kitty in front of the heater.
When I am feeling like I just want something cozy and enveloping as a break from medicine, I have been enjoying Atelier Cologne Ambre Nue. I have just a little bit of it, hopefully enough to last the winter. It is not an overly sweet or cloying amber scent, but is definitely warming, and although fairly delicate, holds its own against heavier winter perfumes that would upset my fraught nasal membranes right now. I hope to add a bottle to my comfort scent collection so I can count on it to see me through the next few flu seasons.
Efim Volkov
-John Reasinger, Editor
Winter. The very thought brings images of ice covered trees, thick falling snow and smoke billowing from chimneys. A time for wrapping up in one’s favorite sweater or comfy quilt calls for heavier spicier scents that warm the heart as much as the soul. I often thumb my nose at traditional “seasonal” perfumes and wear what I like…there are; however, some times when nothing but a thick oriental perfume will do. These are two of my favorites…
ROBERT PIGUET Baghari is one of my favorite classic oriental floral perfumes. A bright aldehydic opening with both citrus fruit and blossom greets the nose sharply before mellowing to a delightful floral mélange. Aurélien Guichard took the most powerful flowers and twisted them into a stunning beauty. Majestic rose, sweet jasmine, dry violet and cool steely iris sing out in a bold and beautiful floral song. It is the finish, however, that really gets me. Like a scorching scirroco wind, crumbly amber, smoky vetiver, musk and vanilla arrive and dessicate the flowers slightly. All that is left is a spicy sweet balm with haunting memories of flowers.
PRADA Amber Pour Homme Intense is a definite go-to scent for me on cold days when I need something a little deeper, darker and masculine. No one was more surprised than me that I liked this particular flanker even better than the original! It opens with the same clean bergamot/orange blossom/mint accord but that is short-lived. Dry geranium and saffron capture the classy scent of men’s by-gone vintage scents, before it becomes a swarthy and oriental dream. Anything vaguely resembling the original is now gone. Sweet scented balms mesh with incense, patchouli and just a hint of leather over sandalwood and musk.
Edie Sedgewick
-Valerie Vitale, Contributing Editor
Etat Libre D’Orange, Jasmin et Cigarette is definitely theatrical. Jasmine comes spilling forth on my skin, and then there is the anticipation BEFORE the cigarette is lit. The soft pack that gets scrunched in my mother’s purse, the smack smack of the pack that hits the palm of her hand and leads us to a strong waft of COLD tightly packed slightly sweet-dried tobacco. There is a happy overall waxiness to the fragrance that makes it a bit quirky, but it somehow remains a diva.
Wear Caron Tabac Blond and you can channel all the smoking suffragettes who wore it in 1919 (created by Ernest Daltroff). Its strength and attitude has the ability to ignite any grey single-digit day. This is a full throttle fragrance that is leathery and smoky. Its strong spine is a spicy floral note that slowly changes to rest on an amber y base adding warmth and an afterglow.
For our draw we have five full bottles from our "best scents for winter cold weather". We also love Freddie Mercury of Queen singing Outside in A Winter's Tale
50 ml of Gaiac by Parfums M. Micallef. Courtesy of HypoLuxe the US distributors (Meet Jeff Dames at Elements Showcase at #1-15)
50 ML of Carner Barcelona Rima XI created by Sonia Constant. Courtesy of Babalu Miami, The US Distributors (meet Sara Carner, Greg and Paolo at Elements Showcase at booth #1-06) Editor's Note: Congratulations to Sara Carner as Rima XI is a finalist for the Indie Fifis 2013
50 ML of Etat Libre D'Orange Jasmine et Cigarette created by Antoine Lie. Courtesy of Jean-Luc and Nicole of EuroScentsUSA
50 ML of Baghari EDP created by Aurélien Guichard. Thanks to our friends Joe and Debra at Robert Piguet Parfums
30 ml of Amber Nue Cologne Absolue by Ralf Schwieger courtesy of Gerard, Sylvie and Christophe of Atelier Cologne
Tell us which of the five fragrance offered in the draw are amongst your favorite winter scents or ones you would want to try, and the temperature outside as you read this post. Draw ends January 27, 2013.
We announce the winners only on site, and on our Facebook page, so Like Cafleurebon and use our RSS option…or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume










































It’s 2ºC just outside London right now, so warming up! Thank you for the reviews. I’d most like to try the Amber Nue because I love amber and because Ralf Schwieger is one of my favorite perfumers.
I would most like to try Gaiac by M. Micallef because you make it sound so very warm and sensuous.
Right now it’s 44 degrees in my soggy, grey corner of the world.
I have been longing to try Gaiac since I first read the notes. It is currently 46 degrees and raining in the PNW.
I would like to try Carner Barcelona Rima XI. Tonight we have windy weather with +6C
I think I would really like Carner Barcelona Rima XI or Baghari, although I have not tried them. The temperature here is 21 F or -6C. Thank you for this draw.
I loved Gaiac when I first smelled it last year and had frankly forgotten about it until now. I think a bottle of that would be most lovely on this rainy day. 36 degrees and dropping here in the Siskiyou Mountains…
I would love to try Rima XI by Carner Barcelona because of the beautiful poetic description of the scent.
We don’t have winter here because I’m from the tropics but it’s currently 18C outside.
I would like to win Guiac by Micallef … sounds great! Temp around 15 degrees C.
I would love to try the Gaiac and the Amber Nu has been on my list to sample for awhile now so thanks for the review. It’s currently 51 degrees and dropping in the US southwest. (Yesterday it was 73 degrees and felt like Spring!) I hope you feel better soon
We are currently having a heatwave and bushfires, today 36 degrees C.
I would love to try Gaiac by M Micallef, and I think I would not wait for cold weather to wear it!
The weather in Southern California is an unseasonably cold 53° degrees. I had to turn the heater on and wear my footed pajamas. The scent that I have a hankering for is Rims XI it soft spicy allure seems perfect for these cold and rainy nights. Thanks for another wonderful draw
I would love to try Baghari for it sounds amazing! Outside, now are -2 celsius degrees and it is snowing. Thanks for the draw.
Your description of Giac makes me salivate to try it! It’s a balmy 5 degrees here in the Pacific Northwest.
Would love to try Gaiac, as it sounds amazing.
The temperature outside is -3°C, which is a relief after yesterday morning’s -19°C.
It’s 52 Fahrenheit in balmy California. Although this is cold for us
I really liked this list of winter fragrances because it was so diverse
I love all things jasmine so Jasmine et cigarette , gaiac and Rima XI would be my choices
Very poetic description of Rima , baghari and jasmine et cigarette
Lovely writing
I will fall asleep now and dream of Andalusia and a fragrant lover
I never heard of Carner Barcelona until Cafleurebon
You guys are great source for what’s new and exciting
Thank u for also writing so much about artisan perfumers
I lurk alot and don’t comment that often but I read you almost every day
I would like to try Gaiac.
It’s a cool (for us) 25C with loads of rain in the tropics
Hey, we are starting to warm up now (Sat morn) to 25F in northern Ohio. At least the sun is shining, which is something we don’t see much of this time of year. I would be happy to win any of these scents, but you make Gaiac sound so wonderful, that I have to go with that one.
I think you were reading my mind. I have been craving M. Micallef’s Gaiac for the past month. Maybe my craving will be rewarded with a bottle!! It’s been much too cold this past week (right now it’s 25 degrees outside) and I need a little warmth!
Actually Steve, I read your blog and wondered when you would pay us a visit. I know you are a fan of Gaiac too.
I want to try Gaiac, Rima XI & Amber Nue. The temperature right now is 44°F.
I love Gaiac, and would love to try the Rima XI. It’s a relatively balmy 57 degrees here in my part of Northern California.
It is freezing cold here, with great winds that make it hard to go outside, so I cuddle up and dream of Gaiac, or Ambre nue!
I would love to win Gaiac by M. Micalleff. The temperature is -2 degrees centigrade here in Ireland. Cold wet and very gr´¥!
I am most attracted to the notes in Baghari, and I am intrigued by this fragrance. I have never smelled it, but it sounds lovely. I’m also very tempted by Jasmine et Cigarette. Fascinating description.
Jasmine Et cigarette, by ELO. Not tobacco, but cigarette: this scent intrigues me. I can imagine the scent of the nocturnal warm-weather jasmine warming up my senses on this -24 Montreal winter evening. Brrr!
I do like Micallef Gaiac, but I would love to own Rima XI. It’s 50 degrees here in the East Bay of San Francisco.
GAIAC for sure! 35 degrees.
Carner Barcelona Rima XI works for me. 0 °F here.
Outside is-1C °, which means 30.2F ° , sunny, no wind. A very nice winter day with the remains of snow. All the five fragrances sounds great.Carner Barcelona Rima XI is my choice.
I’d like to try the Rima XI. It’s 30 ° F here and we’re getting an ice storm.
I’d like to be wrapped up in Gaiac on a cool cool nite like this. It’s 24C here. Not freezing I know but gloomy skies + comfort scent is perfect.
In winter I am dreaming of baghari or Gaiac. It’s not freezing now but a hug from special perfume is nevertheless comforting at all times.
Its 55F as I am writing here. Beautiful comfort scent needs no temperature or time to do its magic. I would pick Rima XI or Jasmine et cigarette.
THanks
I would love to win Gaiac.Gaiacwood is one of my favorite notes.It’s currently 29 degrees here in NYC.Thanks for the draw!
It’s a windy 56 degrees here in N.County San Diego going down to 41 degrees. I love woody fragrance. The Gaiac sound marvelous. I would love to try it.
My vigorating scent for winter is atelier vanilla noir insensee…Warms the soul:-)